Getting Enough?

Home Photo Gallery My Motorcycle Writings Web Advice

Usenet Newsgroups Mothers Club Stories Mensa

Usenet Writings
Pregnancy
Discipline
Sleeping
Labor
Breastfeeding
Etiquette

Is Baby Getting Enough to Eat?

My experiences

©1994 Beth Weiss, Posted to misc.kids.pregnancy Usenet newsgroup, September 18, 1994

I wrote this when someone wrote that it wasn't unheard of for breastfed babies to become malnourished.

Although it is not "unheard of", it is also very rare, and I found these bald three lines to be fear mongering, without enough information to help parents feel confident that isn't happening to their child.

Most babies are weighed at their 2 week well-baby checkup, which gives the baby's medical provider an opportunity to ensure that the baby is gaining weight.  If the baby is gaining satisfactorily, then he or she is getting enough milk.

Second, most healthy women CAN produce enough milk, so that if the baby's weight gain at 2 weeks, (or one month or two months, etc.) is not sufficient, then the mother can be given assistance in increasing her milk supply.  Most women can increase their milk supply my nursing on demand, getting lots of rest, and eating well.

From the stories people have told me, when a woman says she has "insufficient milk supply" it often means that the baby was eating often, or breasts didn't feel hard to the touch, or that she wasn't leaking anymore--none of which are indicators of insufficient milk supply.

The most common suggested "cure" for insufficient milk supply can often CAUSE or increase the problem--formula supplementation interferes with milk production, since milk supply is based on demand.

I'd like to add one anecdote--this happened at Jordan's 2 week well-baby checkup.  Even with all of the reading I'd done, I was worried about him getting enough milk, and it seemed he was eating all of the time.  The doctor's reply: "You can always supplement with formula."--which I knew was pretty much guaranteed to bring an early end to breastfeeding--so I ignored him.  (and changed doctors)

But a woman who had read less might well have taken the doctor's suggestion more seriously--and as a validation of her concerns about food intake and schedules, when what she was really asking for was a bit of medical reassurance for her new-mom jitters.  I would have done much better with a reply such as: "He's a full 5 ounces over his birthweight, which means that he's gaining really well.  I know it's hard to be sure, but if you're worried, stop in and we'll weigh him every week or two, and keep track of his progress.  But most newborn breastfed babies eat a lot--it's just what new babies do.  You're doing just great and your little guy is gaining like a champ."

That would have been much better than "You can supplement with formula".  It would have been true, more reassuring, more caring, and more helpful.

Failure to thrive is a concern all new parents have, I think, but regular medical attention catches problems early--and more reassurance is in order for most parents.

Getting Enough? Choosing Pediatrician Pumping for Dad Perservering Just For a While?

Usenet Newsgroups Mothers Club Stories Mensa


©1992-2004 Beth Weiss, All rights reserved
Questions or issues? Contact the
Beth's Home
Why I host with TotalChoice

TotalChoice Web hosting (Total Choice)